









Get a sense of the area and find the key highlights of where you'll be living
AI Property Summary
Experience a top-rated lifestyle in these bright, spacious apartments that feature modern appliances and a welcoming community atmosphere. Located just steps away from local shops, dining, and the waterfront, this community offers the perfect balance of convenience and comfort. These units feature a clean, coastal-inspired aesthetic with light-filled living spaces and private outdoor balconies.





4.7
Very Good
From $3,200 /month
217 W Broadway, Port Jefferson, NY 11777, USAShow on Google Maps
4.7
Very Good
Based on 62 Google reviews
Powered by Google
AI Review Summary
This property offers a truly wonderful living experience, with a fantastic location that's walking distance to shops, restaurants, and the waterfront, alongside spacious units featuring quality appliances and plenty of sunlight. Residents consistently praise the respectful community and the attentive management team, who foster a comfortable and welcoming environment.
These are the 5 latest Google reviews for Overbay Apartment Community at Port Jefferson.
Reviews tend to skew toward strong opinions. They're a useful guide, but may not reflect the typical day-to-day experience.
5
June 2025
We lived at Overbay since they opened four years ago. Our time at Overbay has been nothing but wonderful. Jake is extremely responsive, helpful, trustworthy, and an overall great property manager and person. The rest of the team is also great and was always there if we needed something. The location is perfect, across the street from the water, and walking distance to awesome restaurants, bars, and shops. We cannot recommend this complex enough!
5
August 2024
I was a former resident of Overbay from when it had opened 3 years prior and stayed there for that duration. The staff from pre leasing was super helpful and my experience there was nothing but exceptional. Staff attentive to residents needs, comfortable environment, and perk of coffee/bagels during the weekdays. Jake who is the manager currently is very helpful and would highly recommend apartment complex to anyone looking in the area.
August 2024
My family and I had a great time living at Overbay for the past 3 years and would have continued living there had we not needed to move for job purposes. The apartment is well maintained and efficiently run by James, Jake, and Lou. Whenever any issues came up they were quick to deal with them. The build quality of the apartment is excellent and in our time there we never had any issues with noice. The community is great as well since it’s mostly working professionals living there who are respectful and pleasant.
August 2024
Overbay is truly a place you can call “home.” I have lived in apartments in different states, but I never felt sad when moving out—until we lived in Overbay for three years. There’s no doubt we would have renewed our lease if we weren’t relocating to another state. We stayed in the "Little Bay" unit, which is spacious for a two-bedroom compared to other apartments in the Port Jefferson area. The apartment features smart, full-sized appliances, plenty of sunlight, and is located near the main street, with nice restaurants and shops just a 5-minute walk away. Additionally, James, Jake, Lou, and the cleaning lady (I'm sorry I never got your name during those three years) are incredibly friendly and top-notch. Plus, the owner of this company is extremely attentive. My husband once overheard one of their meetings, and he mentioned that the apartment owner even took care to ensure that residents could conveniently take and use the coffee cups provided in the morning. Last but not least, the residents here are very respectful, making communal living a pleasant experience!
August 2024
Wonderful place to live. The apartments are set with quality appliances and details, unlike other luxury style apartments that look good at a glance but have shoddy details this complex is put together very well. Administration is very responsive and friendly. Location was incredible. Being able to walk to downtown Port Jefferson was convenient and fun. If I didnt move far away for a new job I would still be there.
5
5
5